Mother of ‘caged’ autistic child appeals for assistance

The cage

A 38-year-old mother of four is appealing for help for her 15-year-old son who is suffering from Autism.

Helen Carbon says she is “frustrated and don’t know where again to turn to” as she seeks help for her son Carvell Edwards who, one week ago, she had to  place in a cage.

“I have gone to everyone, Dr. Benjamin, (Health Minister) Julius Timothy, social welfare and all and no one seems to be able to give me peace of mind,” she said.

“The boy had to be housed in the cage because he damages and destroys everything in his way and is very disruptive in the neighborhood,” Carbon said almost in tears.

She explained that her son has had that illness from age three and now she does not know where to turn.

“Sometimes he is violent and the medication is not working, it’s left to me and my grandfather to pay for his medication…… we are helpless and frustrated and do not know where to turn and what to do so we now have to house him in a prison cage,” she stated.

The child peering through the cage

The disease he suffers from is also called “Autistic Spectrum Disorder (ASD), Pervasive Developmental Disorder (PDD)”.

Autism is a disorder that is usually first diagnosed in early childhood.

The main signs and symptoms of autism involve communication, social interactions and repetitive behaviors.

Research shows that the disease “Autism” remains a challenging condition for children and their families, but the outlook today is much better than it was a generation ago when most people with autism were placed in institutions.

Edwards is hoping that the authorities in Dominica will find some way to relieve her plight.

Disclaimer: The comments on this page do not necessarily reflect the views of Inc. All comments are approved by before they are posted. We never censor based on political or ideological points of view, but we do try to maintain a sensible balance between free speech and responsible moderating.

We will delete comments that:

  • violate or infringe the rights of any person, are defamatory or harassing or include personal attacks
  • are abusive, profane or offensive
  • contain material which violates or encourages others to violate any applicable law
  • promote hatred of any kind
  • refer to people arrested or charged with a crime as though they had been found guilty
  • contain links to "chain letters", pornographic or obscene movies or graphic images
  • are excessively long and off-message

See our full comment/user policy/agreement.


  1. March 6, 2012

    i dont think locking him up and isolating him is the answer nuh mommy, what u shud do is tie his hands and legs durin the day with peice of cloth an put him to sit down. thats what they did my cousin. He is a human being like everyone else… he is not a dog… i hope am not being rude by sayin this but i feel more sorry for the child.

  2. Anonymous 2
    March 5, 2012

    I may seem a bit mean in my comment to some but before i do comment I would like to say I am not. First question: Why is everything the government’s fault? No I am not associated with any political party. But on a serious note. This child is 15 years old. Autism is something that can be controlled. So the mother has been waiting for help for 15 years? simple things such as loud noises or even changes in an autistic persons routine can have them go into a temper tantrum. Autism is different for every person who suffers from it. Has the mother done any research on her own in reference to the disorder or has just gone on what the doctors have told her?

    Parents of autistic children have a part to play in the control of this disorder and locking them up or chaining them to beds is not going to work. It is not their fault and neither it the fault of the parents or the government. I would not recommend or support putting all these children in one home. They are not orphans, they have homes and families. A center where they can go during the day would be fine. Parents should be trained on what to do and what not to do.

    Simple characteristics of being human that “normal” people simply are born with, these children have to learn them. Patience is something that parents need to have, it is your child. They have speech issues, socializing problems and some would prefer to be alone. Try to be in the body of an autistic child. It can be frustrating and so retaliating should be expected just like when babies cry when they can’t speak yet when they would like someone to understand them.

    It is sort of like that for autistic children, their brains can’t make simple connections and they can’t put meaning to the words they hear.

    Stop pointing fingers at who is to blame. Children are involved here and it is a shame that the first thing people do is point fingers. WORK TOGETHER, STOP BEING SO SMALL MINDED, FIND A SOLUTION AND REMEMBER CHILDREN ARE INVOLVED!

    Those of you who know nothing about it do some research. And please remove this child from the cage, i can tell you he is scared, but he can’t say that to you. No he is not wicked.

    • Anonymous
      November 30, 2014

      Do not speak unless you are from this culture. Does she seem like the type to use Google to you? The incredible thing here is you’ll never even realize you’re the ignorant one here.

  3. Malatete
    March 5, 2012

    We stand condemned as a nation! We spend millions on political campaigns, find the money to sponsor fetes right, left and centre. Provide first class travel for the leadership of our impoverished little country, all over the globe. Yet, we can not take care of this? Where are our priorities, our compassion. We promote ourselves as a caring, especially friendly nation. Are we?
    Situations like these need to be taken care of first before we even think of the next bottle of black label.Yes I am guilty too but am more than happy for my tax money to be prioritized for spending on the wellbeing of our disenfranchised.

  4. Anonymous
    March 5, 2012

    this woman have a problem even if her child is autistic why couldn’t she put him in a room?have the child caged up like an animal.

  5. mental health
    March 4, 2012

    it is so sad what this mother is going through having to beg for care for her child with a “common” mental health issue. even more sad that Dr.Benjamin is not helping more, he needs to tune down his ego admit that he doesnt have what it takes to deal with all the cases and have the government help provide a proper facility and more experienced doctors to help him, smdh and this man says he could have delt with sarahlynn augustine case, he cant even handle autism. lord help dominica

  6. Teacher
    March 3, 2012

    Ok, Where is this cage? Because this is any indication that it is where this young man is living, then we know it is misleading. better yet, it is a lie.

  7. Teacher
    March 3, 2012

    That story is very misleading. That child is not in any cage. Did they even visit the home, right there in Pottersville.

  8. Help Us
    March 3, 2012

    Come on people this child does not have a disease and he is NOT disabled. He is MENTALLY CHALLENGED.

    We need to think more positive and at the same time choose our words correctly!

  9. oioioi
    March 3, 2012

    at least if you keeping the child separated make the environment look less hostile. paint the walls put up a curtain, give the child a bed, some paper and crayons some toys some thing.

  10. yoyo
    March 2, 2012

    After hearing this lady plight, it only reiterate to me how backward and prejudice our country is.
    This is not a problem which started yesterday, but hundred of years ago.we are probably some of the most non-compassionate people in the entire world.
    We are probably some of the most ignorant people in the world.(lack of knowledge). How do you expect to meet the plight of people when our attributes are all of the above? Our small mindedness and prejudices have caused us to stamp out our brothers and sisters because they are not normal as us. After we do those things we go about claiming to be called a child of God, and vehemently ague with people about where we are going to spend eternity. As Jesus would say, hypocrites and vipers.We are such hypocrites that we are even blinded from the true meaning of the world.For those of us who read the bible and say we understand it where are our balls to stand up and demand that our less privilege brothers and sisters have the god given right to live and enjoy everything as our brothers that are more privilege. Jesus, was always looking out for those who were poor, and had less and mandated that we should share with one and other, and love thy neighbor as thy self. If we call our selves god ministers we should take a stance and demand that the Government of this country must put measures in place and provide services that can bring about dignity and respect to our fallen brothers who by no fault of theirs are living in a bad predicament. How can we expect to get God’s blessings if we do not provide the great commandment? We need to be compassionate, strive for justice and get rid of our prejudices, or we will remain backward and many people will die and leave this earth unaware that life have much more to offer than our mickey mouse way of thinking. Shame on Dominica for not caring about our own flesh and blood.
    Presently, am studying the degree of people with intellectual and development disabilities, and my dream is to come home in 5 years and bring a new perspective and vision, and create a voice and awareness for these fallen people. Everybody is worth the same amount by god’s standard and no healthy person have more right on earth than some one with a disability. I am destined to accomplish this desire, because it is God’s will for my life. I must succeed, because it is not my plan, but God’s, and as we know, no one can prevent the will of God from taking place. The Government need to create a special department in their government to take care of people will all kinds of disabilities. Every year the government must allocate a certain amount of funds to pay for those individuals services. These funds must be able to cover the clients room and board, day schooling, medical visits and emergencies, and entertainment.Do we not all just want to be able to have those four basic things in life? the government must set up a program within the social security whereby,they will provide a monthly check to take care of those individuals needs. Anyway, i do not have enough space to elucidate all my knowledge and ideas , so i will reveal the rest at time.

  11. Muslim_Always
    March 2, 2012

    This is the second case I’ve read so far regarding challenged people. It begs one to infer there are more unreported incidents of challenged individuals who are not receiving the proper care they deserve.

    We hope that these issues are reported and dealt with timely and effectively.

  12. hmmm
    March 2, 2012

    Very sad. But it’s still not clear, what kind of help is needed. What would help this boy and family best at this moment?

    Is it a doctor to review the medication prescribed?
    is it a professional caregiver to look after the boy?
    is it an institution for the boy to live in?
    is it a medication/money for medication?
    does this boy have anything to do – books, educational games etc? being in an empty room doesn’t help his condition.

    DNO, could you please provide more information or leave contact details of the family. I think there are people who wish to help, whether themselves or with finding some organizations/people, who can help.

    • show me the money
      March 2, 2012

      my dear, hold on there is not a thing any one can do for you, i have a child with that same thing .

      find out what he likes,the things he more interested in.

      mine love the beach and i would spend the whole day there with him. he couldnot attend public school so he went to a private school

      watch the foods he eat some foods send them real crazy
      dont give him sugar chocolate, fruits with lots of sugar give him little of it per day and the list go on and on.

      • show me the money
        March 2, 2012

        the medication makes them worst. trust me.

        Like or Dislike: Thumb up 2 Thumb down 0
  13. glo
    March 2, 2012

    Dear Heleen,


  14. Queen
    March 2, 2012

    There was just a wrong diagnosis and consequently the wrong medication prescribed Carbon . An early an accurate diagnosis would prevent this behaviour.

    Very sorry to see your son like this

  15. domincan
    March 2, 2012

    I have worked and have experience with abused women and children, and would loved to come home and show my support, and work to help build and implent programs to help those in need

  16. domincan/ Toronto
    March 2, 2012

    Why is he caged like an animal?? the gonverment should have programs, or a facility to accommodate kids with disabilities,so that they are not locked up like animals. I do however, feel for this woman, because its difficult caring for an autistic child,I have a nephew who’s autistic, and see the the struggles my borthe and wife faces.But with financial support from the goverment here, they are able to put him in proograms for kids with special needs. He is treated like and equal, and is well loved. He is not locked up like an animal.The Government on Dominica needs to start really shifting their focus on such important issues instead of the petty they are often fighting about.

    • anonymous
      March 3, 2012

      I concur.

    • jidg
      March 3, 2012

      Like you said there is no reason for him to be caged but i think we can not always depend on the government to put a program in place. If that young teen can start up her own foundation and do positive things why the can’t an adult do the same. put something in place start their own program. the internet has so much info on autistic kids all over as well as support. why not use these as a resource .

      • Shameless
        March 3, 2012

        Let us be real now; If NOT the government then who? These programs need professional resources that only the government in Dca can provide. The issue is we have too many square pegs in round holes being protected by blinded apologists

        Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0
  17. IJS
    March 2, 2012

    Isn’t there a behavioural specialist on the island now….Mrs Jamie Alleyne Sorhaindo is a specialist in children that have behavioural problems. Ms Carbon try contacting her and see if she can help you or treat your son. I pray it works out for you.

    • tired of talk
      March 2, 2012

      Jamie has tried but again the system frustrates every being of someone who is willing to assist with all their heart. Because this has not been blown out to the media, or one of their friends has a child with this disorder they would budge. Jamie had Brainstorm which worked for the children, but GOVERNMENT refused to step in to help.

      • watching
        March 3, 2012

        government did not refuse to help…i’m guessing by government you mean the necessary authorities…obviously there is more to this

        Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0
  18. Laura
    March 2, 2012

    I feel for this mother. Dominica does not have the resources to help families affected by having a child with ASD. I work for a renowned facility in Canada that deals with children with autism. My heart lies in Dominica and I have been trying to get through to anyone in the government to see if there is funding available to start a program for these families, yet have received no response. I would be qualified to set up a facility or clinic in which I could perform behaviour therapy with these children! I could also train lots of young people on how to work with these children! In addition, the team I work with in Canada are willing to come down and do assessments for free if the government can help us get down there as we are a non-profit agency!

    If anyone knows of someone I can contact, I would appreciate that information because I know that this family is not the only family in Dominica! The psyc ward with Dr. Benjamin is not the place to put these children! Please help me try to get funding from the government for these families and children!

    • tired of talk
      March 2, 2012

      There is Melina Fountain from the Min of Education who is qualified in that area. We mothers with autistic children have knocked countless times on the door of the Ministry of Education and they have practically turned their backs on us. If they had a child with this disorder they might have a clue what our plight is. As far as I am concerned THEY DO NOT CARE A DAMN!!!!!!

      • show me the money
        March 2, 2012

        am a dominican living abroad and i got good help

        Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0
  19. DA woman
    March 2, 2012

    Let me point out that autism is NOT a disease and he should not be medicated.

    He and his family needed help from the day he was diagnosed, but unfortunately we do not have the facilities in Dominica to deal with it.
    Unfortunately I can’t help, but I have worked with autistic children and I have seen them strive, because the society in which I live provide for the needs of their autistic children. It takes alot on the part of the parents and the community to understand what is going on with the child, inorder tht he or she can have a pleasant life.

    Having an autistic child is no different than having one who is either blind, deaf or dumb.

    • Anonymous
      March 3, 2012

      Yes it is different. Kids who are unable to hear, see or speak don’t have behavioural problems etc. unless they also have a diagnosis of Autism.

      There is much, much more to an autistic child compared to a child with disabilities like not been able to hear, see or speak. Also, all autistic kids are not the same.

    • Anonymous
      March 3, 2012

      An autistic child is very different than one who can’t see, hear or speak because an autistic child has a lot more issues to learn to deal with if at all compared to a child who can’t speak, hear or see.

      There are also different stages/levels of autism which means that one autistic child cannot really be compared to another.

  20. Aye Dominique
    March 2, 2012

    This is now becoming a serious issue, we see more and more kids being born with this disease, however, our policy makers have taken a do it on your own approach. It is a proven fact that these children after reaching a certain age, cannot live within the confines of a home but must and I repeat must be placed in a specialized institution.

    Do we have such an institution? The answer is no! Do we have persons trained to deal with these conditions, the answer is no!

    So many graduates with psychology training, when they come back they offer them jobs in the ministry as typist.

    Government has not invested wisely in its human resource. A couple of these graduates should be further invested in, sent abroad to do specialized training to deal with these conditions, and in addition, a home need to be organized for these kids.

    We have so many doctors unspecialized on the island, no one is paying attention to get these young people specialized. They waiting for these people to take the same underpaid salaries to go study. These professionals are under dire stress, they operate under dire stress, low salaries, poor working condition and no incentive for further development.

    However when there is a need we see our government quick to import cuban doctors and doctors from elsewhere, who as soon as they learn the system could not care one hoot about government work they running down to Ross with government vehicle and gas to make extra money for them to get rich in Dominica overnight while the house officers which are the Dominicans who can’t afford to go specialize are overloaded with work at the hospital.

    Government needs to put its money where its mouth is and stop waiting for something terrible to happen like what happened in Grammar School to act. We need to fix our health system! We need to fix the welfare division!

    • Jay
      March 2, 2012

      We do not need to institutionalize children who are diagnoses with autistic tendency. First they are children, and then their diagnoses are second. They can function in a regular classroom setting as children without autism; however early intervention at our schools are needed for any child with a diagnosis of autistic tendency.

    • jidg
      March 3, 2012

      its not a disease its a disorder and if from an early age the children who have it are taught certain life skills and other social ones then there is no need for them to be caged. In the caribbean- Dominica- we do not have persons trained to early identify this disorder so as a result it becomes to late before steps are taken if any. i think the job falls on the parents you need to be aggressive in seeking help for your kids, in looking for the help that they need so that disorders like these and many others can be detected early. We can not sit and wait for the government to do it for us… one person mentioned that they are part of a program in Canada that deal with such kids. I say if you really want to make a difference you should not wait for the government to say yes you can come take up the challenge and do what you think you have to …

    March 2, 2012

    Autism is not a disease it is a disability and it is so sad and wrong for a mother to put her disabled child in a cage. My heart goes out to you but more to the child!! This child already feels different and knows that something is wrong with him and because this toddler is not accepted with the rest of the family he thinks that is why he’s put into a cage.
    That is a form of mental abuse on top of his disability. It’s great to seek or cry out for help but mean while the child requirements are important. His requirements are challenging and needs to be met.
    The government should assist families who faces these challenges and should build a special school for these children. Parents also has to educate themselves and do research. These kids need special activities/games, love, care, art, music and group activities. NOT PUTTING THEM IN CAGES!!!!

  22. March 2, 2012

    This may have some information resources. It has a Transition kit print out dealing with teenagers

  23. Alwaysbless
    March 2, 2012

    Everyone’s sayin they’re feelin sorry for this lady, her family and her son but it would make her feel much better if someone could give this lady an adress, the name of a place or somewhere she could get some real help and solution, that i believe would help her more. I live in an European country and I know hear she would get help. And even in Dominica she could get help, but all depends to the Gov’mt, and the Social S.,if they are really willing to help this family and that boy. And i’m hoping by Gods grace that they will do everything they can to help you dear. God bless you.

  24. just a suggestion
    March 2, 2012

    Perhaps this mother could research specialist institutions in US, Canada etc. and send them a copy of the DNO article. You never know one of these institutions may offer to sponsor the child’s treatment. I feel her pain and wish her and her child the specialist help they really need.

  25. Dominica abroad
    March 2, 2012

    Please, Please, Please DNO put pressure on the people who can get this lady and her son some help. No one wants to see the child caged. She has dealt with this for long time and now she really really needs help. This is when Dominica’s government should show concern for its people.

    ADMIN for DNO please keep us posted.

  26. HTC
    March 2, 2012

    It is a very difficult situation and i know it’s not easy but placing him in a cage is not helping the situation you are making him aggressive. DNO can you please post her information i am willing to help. I reside in the US and will be in Dominica next month.

  27. Dominican
    March 2, 2012

    As someone who works with kids and adults with Autism I empathize with you. There are means of managing behaviors. For the record there is no treatment for Autism. While many here say dont medicate sometimes medication is a big help in addition to the behavior modification to assist families. Also the types of food you give your child. Reduce flour or wheat based products. Gluten is not a good thing for kids with autism. You want to givie him alot of plant based foods.

    You can also help him by trying to be calm and soothing. What is he like when he is not having behavioral issues. While it seems like locking him up is the best approach it really is doing more harm to him than good.

    Hope this helps.

    • Anonymous
      March 3, 2012

      I know a lot of autistic kids who are eating wheat based products and their behaviours are just fine so removing wheat from the diet only works for some kids. And I also know kids who are not medicated and are doing fine. These kids don’t need medications, or to be institutionalized or special schools. A lot of these medication just create side effects that make behaviours worse. We need to remember they are kids first who need to socialize like the rest of us not just lumped together and dealt with. They can attend the same schools like the average kid just need to have some classes/classrooms that meet their individual needs. Some autistic kids also function quite well in regular classrooms and some of them are even smarter that the “non’autistic” student. A lot of time, investment, love, understanding and specialized trained individual, teachers etc. is what they need. The little boy in the cage could really be a smart child but nobody knows that because he was probably labelled as retarded or unable to learn.

      To Ms Carbon, please get your son out of that cage and rearrange your home to suit him. He pulls things down keep them out of his reach, read to him, teach him when you can and love him more and more each day.

  28. Country
    March 2, 2012

    Don’t Fret the meek shall inherit the earth. My heart breaks for mother and child. I am not well, but in the past I worked with Autistic children very much like your son. It is very difficult to help them when they bite and kick and spit etc. But our program managed to help them so much. We exposed them to animals. They apeared to love Horses, they became quiet and smiled and it was just wonderful to see them in control on top of a gentle horse. Thank you for sharing your story I pray this will help to educate people on this very troubling problem. God Bless

  29. sad
    March 2, 2012

    i see the need for all of us as dominicans to be each others keepers. let us be more concerned about each other,let us work hand in hand as a NAtION for the good of all dominicans.
    let us not judge this mother because this child is in a cage, she is desperate and is reaching out for help. let us do it together.

    • Up and rising
      March 2, 2012

      @Sad. This is exactly what I was thinking of. We as Dominicans need to return to those times when we really cared about and looked out for each other. We can no longer rely on the government to solve all problems, but rather should come together as a community and nation to assist.

      Another blogger earlier mentioned the setting up a link on DNO to source funds. That’s great because not only can these funds be used to assist the mother in need but also it can be used to source qualified persons in the region to give the necessary training for these parents.

    • blessedlove
      March 2, 2012

      blessed love brother

  30. Justice and Truth
    March 2, 2012

    I feel sorry for this mother. She has a crucial and valid concern which she cannot handle on her own as well as taking care of her other children. It is a sorry sight to see a child in a cage. She had no alternative but to place him in there. The government must assist this lady.

    She is in dire need of government assistance for her autistic child. The thought crossed my mind that he may be frustrated. He is a person too. Due to his situation, he is unable to relate to anyone. He may also be indoors all the time, unable to communicate with others and of his feelings. This could frustrate him which is why he throws a tantrum and damages the household items. Consider a baby or young child who has not yet learned to speak and communicate performing the identical act. Obviously something within him is causing this behavioral pattern. Whatever is in him needs to be released. He should be among people, to be able to laugh and talk, the latter, in whatever manner he could, with especially those who have the identical or similar problem. A special home and/or a special school would aid him in this respect.

    Medication may work for only a while. The body gets accustomed to medication and then will no longer react to it. This occurs to adults who suffer from an ailment. It also depends on the type of medication which could be effective to calm him and deter him from throwing household items around. The doctor who administers to this child should be fully aware of this and try some other medication which hopefully will stabilize him.

    In bygone years parents who had retarded, handicapped and autistic children did not receive assistance from the government. They were the ones who took care of their children with (probably) no help, financially or physically from the government welfare services. I visualize that this could be expensive, tiring and frustrating for them. Furthermore mothers are becoming older and they may not have the strength as previously to take care of the children especially in the case as her son.

    I view the present situation in Dominica as more progressive than in former years. The government should look into the possibility of having a home and also a school constructed for these children where they could be properly cared for and probably learn something. This should commence when the children are able to attend school

    From the moment parents recognize the problem, they should consult a doctor to examine and diagnose the child’s condition and provide confirmation that the children suffers from this ailment and is in need of help; that the parent(s) would require medical and physically help.

    What a coincidence! At this moment I am writing this, the Holy Mass on Eternal Word Television (EWTN) has commenced on Catholic Radio. The prayer at the commencement of Mass is for “Autistic children, their parents/family and doctors who take care of them and that a cure will be found for this illness.”

    Continuing, some people may make the statement that the government does not have the funding for this purpose. This is an important cause which should not be overlooked and caste aside. The government must take care of its people and especially those who are “special needs” ones. In time and hopefully soon enough, the government will have to find the funding to aid those children. The government should present this concern to a relevant non-profit Agency. They should seek advice and with the hope that the Agency will assist with the funding.

    The workers in the home would have to take a relevant course and be trained in order to administer to those children whom, today, are considered “people of special needs”.

    I recognize that this would be an expensive undertaking. Another suggestion is that a school should be constructed for those children with special needs. This would also require specially trained employees who will be able to administer to them. When they are old enough they should be enrolled in such a school. There they would participate in activities suitable for them with other children of special needs. Parents would notice a marked difference in their child of special needs.

    The government should conduct a research on how many children of special needs there are in each village and town and the possibility of opening such a home/school. May this be done, in Jesus Name, I pray.

    God’s blessing and peace to the parents who have children of special needs and who are taking care of them under difficult circumstances as this lady and mother and also to others who are taking care of those children.

    May a cure be indeed found for autism and all other ailments as downs syndrome, cystic fibrosis and other ailments. There are many.

    • ....
      March 2, 2012

      ur comments are so lengthy…..wile we are grateful for ur insight on juss about any topic…it annoying….u sound like a certain ” journalist” that has an opinion about every and anything to the point where he is becomin a lughing stock among those he feel are less intellectually inclined than he is…am not dissing you..i juss think for someone who warrants such a large amount of space u should juss set up ur own blog!

      • Justice and Truth
        March 2, 2012

        @ ….

        It is obvious that this writing is not for people as you and also does not pertain to you. Just bypass such writing for you will not comprehend it.
        You give me a lot to write about. What goes around comes around. Fools laugh at their ownself. This is one reason why some people do not progress in life. They are not willing to learn from others and those who are more intelligent than they are. I feel sorry for you unloving, senseless, and inconsiderate person that you are. Learn something from intelligent people.
        The world consists of intellectual people and less intellectual ones and everyone should know their place and where they belong in this category. This is in addition to minding your business, knowing your place and where you fit in and not offering advice to those who are educated and intellectual than you are. That is the problem with you who are less intellectually- inclined as you have admitted.
        There are some people who are envious of others, their intellect and what they write. Intelligence could be hereditary. It could commence right in the mothers’ wombs and after they are born through their parents discipline and education.
        It is like being envious of ones “mortal and spiritual gifts” as endowed by the Holy Spirit. This is one of the sins, a grievous one against the Holy Spirit. You are in dire need of mortal and spiritual education and enlightenment.
        You must first learn to speak English, spell and correctly and be articulate prior to utilizing a computer and posting comments, criticism and negative ones. It indicates that you are a jealous and an unhappy person who also lack peace and are unable to generate it to others be it in writing.
        This is the problem with some people of today as you who own computers. These days nearly everyone owns a computer, educated and non-educated and who do not know how to operate or as much as search for the correct words and spelling.
        I do believe that prior to purchasing a computer, they should learn the above. They are the ones, as you who become the laughing stock of those who read your “poor language and spelling.” :twisted: :mrgreen: :twisted: :mrgreen: :twisted: :mrgreen: Do you think that we who are intellectual/educated are not laughing at the poor language and spelling that you post on this Website and which make no sense whatsoever, giving others a poor impression about some of you who also laugh at intellectuals? I also believe that you disgrace this Website. I do think that you should be ashamed of yourself.
        Intellectual people would appreciate what intellectual people state and write. They would comprehend them and never laugh at them. You need to be transformed but I do believe this is beyond you and you will never change.
        You are in no position and out-of-place to offer advice to those who are more intellectual than you are. Do you think that intellectuals would take advice from non-intellectuals? Know your place. You fail to comprehend common sense and important and sensible writing.
        The writing is long for people as you who may not comprehend certain jargons, educational and medical terms because of your limited capabilities.
        Advice is needed for some people, no exception government – politicians, doctors, etc. and people as you.
        Dominica has a grave problem and this is also assisting people who are vulnerable as the disabled and those who take care of them. This needs to be rectified.
        It appears that something is radically wrong that the mother of this poor child who is autistic is unable to receive government assistance. If people as you are not able to comprehend that and what is written, then you are still “a baby, a child who still needs milk and not solid foods” (Holy Scripture) who also need to return to elementary school and learn the basics. May God assist you accordingly.

        Like or Dislike: Thumb up 1 Thumb down 5
    • kush
      March 2, 2012

      wayyyyyyyyy that comment tooo long !!!!!

      • Anonymous
        March 2, 2012

        bodye all u will kill me wi lol :lol:

        Well-loved. Like or Dislike: Thumb up 4 Thumb down 0
      • sugar
        March 2, 2012

        bodye all u will kill me wi :lol:

        Like or Dislike: Thumb up 3 Thumb down 0
      • Justice and Truth
        March 2, 2012

        @ kush

        Life is a growing and learning process. Bypass it with no derogatory comments. This is the problem with some of you who have been insulting and demeaning others on this Website and who try to prohibit their human right and freedom of speech as dictators and cause them to respond.
        I hope the new regulations of DNO will curtail these insults.
        Some of you who call yourselves Christians need to learn love for others, consideration for their feelings and to treat others as you expect them to treat you – The Golden Rule.
        You have much to learn about communication, respectful dialogue, exchanging ideas, providing your comments be it objecting due to your mentality in a courteous manner, learning what is beneficial from others, On-Line etiquette and good manners.
        Retain what is good for us, appreciate it and discard what is not good. We need to accord others their due rights and dignity.

        Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 2
    • Muslim_Always
      March 2, 2012

      Sir, on a serious note your comments are too lengthy. Summarizing your points would be a much better approach.

      Additionally, your writing reflects hardly any topic sentences that informs us what the rest of the paragraph says thus makes it tiresome for one who simply would like to get the gist of what you would like to communicate.

      Lastly, if you choose to write lengthy paragraphs I suggest they are more organized.

  31. de marine
    March 2, 2012

    the tax payers money spent on that state malice could be well spent on a centre for caring for these children.

    • ....
      March 2, 2012

      which tax payers money? on which state malice? stuuuuppppssssss!

    • watching
      March 3, 2012

      no probs if my tax money would go towards OUR State Palace…get d facts bout everything before you jump to conclusions

  32. tired of talk
    March 2, 2012

    I feel your pain. Having a child with autism is something that only another parent who has the same situation can understand. Society has no clue how painful this can be be. I would suggest:
    1. That government conducts a survey of this current situation to find out who are the families affected
    2. Develop a thorough program with ABA therapy and the likes for children during the day
    3. A night care program for those who are severely affected
    4. Reduce the level of tax paid by families for children suffering with this disorder or similar one
    It is time that this government directs its attention to those who really need help and stop giving out handouts or fulling their pockets, i am in tears reading this article. THIS COUNTRY IS IN PAIN, I AM IN PAIN!!!!!!!

  33. de marine
    March 2, 2012

    alas..i really hope someone would come to your aid most urgently.It would really make me happy if my tax money was reaching people like you,mam instead of those corrupted govt officials who take it and put in the hairy bank…building houses and giving cars to their concubines.the 250 usd a day could go a long way to alleviate your plight.God will make a way soon,mother!!!

    • OH Boy
      March 2, 2012

      @de marine I totally agree with you. And all those that commenting for commenting sake have you all even attempted to contact her local health service to see if something is being done to raise the funds needed.

      “Please GOD help her and hoping she get help soon” doesnt cut it. Off the twenty to hundred comments I expect on this article we could have raised well over $600 already. Don’t you all agree? I am waiting for DNO to setup the link so that I can play my part.

      To all those persons with health care knowledge or experience if you are in Dominica then what’s in a 30 minute drive to Portsmouth and bring a warm meal or pay Rudolph Thomas is Portsmouth for some plywood to help improve the situation

      • watching
        March 3, 2012

        funds? are u sure it will be put to good use??? are u sure that housing is the primary issue? before jumping to conclusions PLEASE get the necessary information about the situation and THEN….

        Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0
  34. retired civil servan
    March 2, 2012

    i know that this woman has alot to cope with. I child that is hyper is a problem far less for a situation like this there are many others and parents do not care

  35. Morihei Ueshiba
    March 2, 2012
  36. over seas
    March 2, 2012

    Alas poor Child

  37. March 2, 2012


  38. aunty
    March 2, 2012

    well my dear like you said you have done your best but you need help. This is beyond you. Take him to chronic ward at PMH and leave him right there.

    someone has to do something to assist him.

  39. Anoushah Alie
    March 2, 2012

    STOP FREAKING MEDICATING HIM; that’s worsening him! I see this so many times, having worked with children with behavorial problems, and the doctors only remedy is to medicate the child. That is bad, because WE ALL know, those medications bring on additional symptoms that is doing more damage to the child! Though, I certainly understand how this illness will drive parent(s) to settle for medication to get a “break” from the actions of a child. My heart goes out to her as a mom myself, but I’ll tell you one thing; NO ONE will label my child nor will they medicate him! Every child is different; many times, children act out to get attention and love, because they feel deprived of it! My suggestion to this mom is–more time with this one; he needs more quality time than he’s getting.

    • Rastafari
      March 2, 2012

      I agree with your comments here. However, when people are not properly educated, it becomes difficult for them to make conscious decision. We are taught to trust doctors, priests, teachers, preachers, politicians and the like. She only wants to help her child. She is doing what she thinks is right, because she has no other recourse. Rastafari!!

    • Anoushah Alie
      March 2, 2012

      I didn’t see the pictures when I first posted, but, also, get him out of the cage! i’m trying to be sincere here with the mom, but, he’s not an animal and does not need to be “caged” picture this—people in prisons act out in rage, because of their confining spaces, much less for this child! :(

  40. Shameless
    March 2, 2012

    Oh Jesus. I feel the lady’s pain. I am happy that she is finally speaking out in her quest to get help. Hopefully the authorities step up to the plate and do what is right for the sake of the child and family alike. In the meantime Mrs. Carbon has to be very careful because the laws on the books “Children and Young Person’s Act #17 of 1970” can send her to jail in a minute if it is found that she mistreats the child in any way.

    May god give her strength and the authorities give her the help the rightfully deserves.

  41. former student
    March 2, 2012


  42. March 2, 2012

    The youth is in his teens there is no reason why this woman and her grandmother should not get some assistance, a violent autistic child is very difficultcto handle and care for let alone a teenager, when a mother has to cage her child like an animal you know she is at her witts end,I worked with autistic kids todler and teenager and as a trained professional it was a constant battle,mom continue to seek help for your son until someone does something, go to every govt agency I dont know what help is available down home,but make your voice heard until someone listens,may God bless you!

  43. Totally Psyched
    March 1, 2012

    Oh my! I feel for the family. Autism is something that should be treated at a very early age and treatment includes intensive behavioral therapy to mold proper behavior. This poor child obviously has fallen through the proverbial cracks. However, please take this child to a psychiatrist to treat his symptoms of agression and agitation. Antipsychotics, antidepressants, and medication for ADHD usually work very well, but therapy to teach him social skills is very important. I know caging him is probably a last resort for the family and that they are obviously overwhlemed. But it is inhumane to keep a child in a cage. So please get help from a psychiatrist soon. Good luck to you.

  44. Stupes
    March 1, 2012

    Dominica has no institution where you can take kids with these problems so they can learn to channel their illness into something meaningful and at least contribute to society in whatever way they can and this is sad. I can understand where you are coming from.Keep trying your best. but putting him a cage might only make him worse.

  45. SaylC
    March 1, 2012

    omg…not only is that parent going through alot bt that child is hurt be cooped up in a cage like an animal is no joke..and he cant do anything about it… Allas that’s real sad…well my prayers out to that family

  46. March 1, 2012

    Housing the child in a cage will only make situations worse. He is most likely angry from the sheer frustration of coping with trying to communicate in a world he cannot truly comprehend and which does not comprehend him. The mother and family must research ways to provide him either clinical therapy that could teach him skills to help him communicate and manage his anger, or they can research online and learn ways they could teach him to cope and communicate. It is a tough and rough road but better late than never. And certainly better than caging him. He may also need to be removed from using the medications he takes. While it may have helped him at a younger age, his growing body and severe hormonal changes at this age of his life can often interact and cause problems with medication. I hope someone will pass this advice on to the mother. She must access all the medical help she can get him, but most of all she and her family must learn how to teach him to cope and help him develop more communication skills. I wish her the best

    • OH Boy
      March 2, 2012

      @Kalinago Woryi…so why do you think she is appealing for help? And further more were you not able to comprehend from the clip that she has been seeking help and that she is at the disadvantage of the poverty syndrome. Those in authority perhaps just sees her and her son as a lost cause. Not so long ago on this same DNO site there were two reports which had over a hundred comments in reality how many of these commentators actually tried to offer help or contacted DNO to ask them to set up a donation page for this cause? Well now I am asking DNO to try and set up a donation page/link in favor of this autistic child and all of us who have so much commenting to do can spend less than a minute donating a dollar or more to help this family seek the appropriate care for their child. Too much BLAH BLAH BLAH and no $$$$$$$$$$$ and direction to the right place to go and the right people to speak to. All you keep getting from the Health Department is that we are looking into it and trying to source the finance. So much intelligence and no common sense. Please DNO let’s look into this link and see how we can raise the funds and select our own people to go and help this family. Not the Ministry of Health or Dr Benjamin let us do it ourselves because if we give them the money we won’t get the satisfaction we need. They are just going to pump him with pills and put him in a room at the PMH mental health section; we want more than that.

      • March 2, 2012

        @Oh Boy – notice that my comments were geared towards the family empowering themselves with the information needed to help them learn how to help the child themselves – IN ADDITION to whatever clinical help they could get. I agree that the family could benefit from public donations, but if they do not learn how to to cope themselves, and how to help the boy cope and communicate, then no money can help. And please do not assume I spend my time posturing from an armchair. If you have the know how, then create the fund and and advertize it. Berating people about sharing their thoughts and opinions is no way to garner support for this family

        Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 2
  47. powder puff
    March 1, 2012

    it is time for the people who like to say they are for the people,to really stept up to the plate and do what needs to be done for the people in need and not for the people with greed.

  48. Maks2772
    March 1, 2012

    I feel your pain MsCarbon..I have a 15yr old autistic daughter..she was diagnosed as mild…Just keep pressing the authorities they have to do something…Good luck.

    March 1, 2012

    Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and autism are both general terms for a group of complex disorders of brain development. These disorders are characterized, in varying degrees, by difficulties in social interaction, verbal and nonverbal communication and repetitive behaviors. While it is true that autism is not something a person simply “grows out of,” there are many treatments that can help children learn new skills and overcome a wide variety of developmental challenges. The government should have services to assist in-home behavioral therapy and school-based programs, assistance should be available to meet the child’s special needs. With the right treatment plan, and a lot of love and support, your child can learn, grow, and thrive.
    Become an expert on your child. Figure out what triggers your kid’s “bad” or disruptive behaviors and what elicits a positive response. What does your autistic child find stressful? Calming? Uncomfortable? Enjoyable? If you understand what affects your child, you’ll be better at troubleshooting problems and preventing situations that cause difficulties. May your child likes to draw or listen to music.
    The DSS should assist you because your child falls under the Disabilities Act. The government should assist children in need and their families in receiving medical evaluations, psychological services, speech therapy, physical therapy, parent counseling and training, assisted technology devices, and other specialized services.

  50. d/a chick overseas
    March 1, 2012

    I feel your plight my dear..God will see you through…just take courage and be strong for your family and your son..these officials don’t understand your situation because they do not have a family member who suffers from it. Be of good courage..I really feel for you.

  51. Shadow Min of Health
    March 1, 2012

    De doc have his psychiatric issues the minister of health ought to comprehend carbon’s plight well he has an autistic son too.The difference he does not live with him.But he knows the deal.he just overs the responsibility

  52. Proofreadering self
    March 1, 2012

    How does Carbon turn into Edwards by the time this story begins and ends? what ever happened to el Supremo’s RED CLINIC?Don’t they care anymore?

  53. Justice and Truth
    March 1, 2012

    Her situation is a sad one. If only I could help her. I do not know what medication he has been given. My instinct informs me that her son may not have been given the correct medication or that his medication needs to be changed. Surely, there should be a medication which could stabilize him. There are children who are autistic who appear to function in a docile manner.
    All I can do is to speak to someone or probably a pharmacist who may be able to help and offer a suggestion. I will do this as soon as possible.
    My dear lady and mother you are not alone. My heart goes out to you. You really need help. I hope and pray that the DA Social Services will be able to assist you.
    Many children worldwide suffer from this illness. I wished that Dominica had a medical home which could house him and others who may be suffering from this ailment where they could receive appropriate medication. For the time being all I can state is to keep praying to God and also ask Him for patience in dealing with your son.
    Do not feel guilty about placing him in that room. You did what you had to do under the circumstances. God knows what you are going through. He has seen your effort in taking care of your son and obtaining help for him.
    May He bless you and send you help for your son. My best wishes to you and for peace of heart and mind.

  54. eyes and ears
    March 1, 2012

    A symptom is communication? I’m confused. What about it?
    And social interaction? Huh? Plz clarify

  55. Autism
    March 1, 2012

    Atusim can not be treated with medication…..behavior therapy is needed at an early age…ABA therapy

  56. bambi
    March 1, 2012

    I work with children with autism, and many children with autism are not violent as adults because they recieve aba therapy at an early age… In stead the govt send all these lawyers to study in a coutry with 70,000 people, why don t they send a few students to complete the ABA course in the us. In the usa special education teachers and licensed social workers are the ones trained to provide ABA therapy….Applied Behavior Analysis therapy

    • Reader
      March 2, 2012

      Bambi – I support that comment. In Dominica we are so closed off to other professions. Sometimes it is heart breaking to see the needs of the country and all it produces are lawyers. There is a huge void especially when it comes to mental health and other conditions.

  57. maria
    March 1, 2012

    We bring our children for immunisation as lambs to the slaughter. thats all I will say

  58. gwa bay
    March 1, 2012

    I feel for the lady but still you cannot put a human in a cage. Take him to psychiatric unit if he is overwhelming. I myself pray for strength if I ever have a child with ASD.

  59. TRUTH
    March 1, 2012

    Please Ministry of Health help this family, they are in need. Be your brothers keeper and show some concern and LOVE.

  60. bush
    March 1, 2012

    If i could help i would. i hope some one give a helping hand to this child and i think they will find a place in the new state house for children with such an illness

  61. Morihei Ueshiba
    March 1, 2012

    :-P .. Here u go
    This daddy of an autistic child reports that all symptoms of #autism are identical to the symptoms of mercury poisoning. He says to be patient for
    two years while chelation removes the mercury and other metals.
    His child gives eye contact now and performs like other students.

  62. KAYA
    March 1, 2012

    :cry: :cry: :cry:

  63. Dominica I love
    March 1, 2012

    There is a very good programe in MA USA I have there number on hand and e-mail maybe you can get information and ask for help or maybe someone can be invited to Dominica to give tips and information/ classes as how to deal with children with Autism.

    visit: or call (413)229-2100

    Home of the SON-RISE PROGRAM

    • Justice and Truth
      March 2, 2012

      @ Dominica I Love

      Can the W.H.O. do this?

  64. dominican
    March 1, 2012

    i pray that u will get help trust in God he will make a way

  65. tish...........
    March 1, 2012

    Allah I feel ur pain wi …………someone needs to get help in order to assist the lady…….it sounds very frustrating buh yet she is still there…… her help her help her…….

  66. 1979 eTErNAL
    March 1, 2012

    The Autism Association of Barbados
    Harambee House
    The Garrison
    St. Michael
    Tel: (246) 424 0455

    hope this provides a window to opportunity…

    you are in my prayers
    don’t lose faith.

    • Anonymous
      March 3, 2012

      Autism must be treated at an early age right now it is too late for any treatment to work for this child.medication given can only treat the child aggression.Anonymous

      • Anonymous
        March 4, 2012

        That is not true, why are you discouraging the lady. It’s never too late and with the right kind of help her child can improve.

        Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

:) :-D :wink: :( 8-O :lol: :-| :cry: 8) :-? :-P :-x :?: :oops: :twisted: :mrgreen: more »

 characters available