COMMENTARY: A Pinch of Salt for April Fools Day

A year ago Baroness Scotland launched the establishment of a Dominica Disaster Resource Center and a Building Back Better Expo that she predicted, would do extraordinary things. As the announcement was made on April Fools Day and nothing has happened since, perhaps it was meant to be taken with a pinch of salt.

This is regrettable, not so much for the no-show of a grand event to attract consultants from outside, but for the lost opportunity to harness our own potential from within. In particular it could have given those displaced by the storm a means of having a say in their future. Handing down prescribed solutions from above, rather than involving every man, woman and child at grass root level, has been a major flaw in the attempt to “Build Back Better”.

DNO readers may remember my commentaries on this subject under the titles: Culture Made Visible; Building Back Differently; Re-locating a Rural Community to a Town Setting and Enabling a Built Environment.

In essence my suggestions are nothing new, for it is how your grandparents would have built back a hundred years ago. They relied on Dominica’s abundance of natural resources. In contributing their labour, they expended more sweat but experienced less stress. Human nature is remarkably resilient: within every man, woman and child there is a basic need to begin building back as soon as the dust has settled: not to sit around waiting.

The fact that earlier generations worked with picks, shovels and wheelbarrows meant that they thought twice before excavating tons of earth. They had a better understanding of the nature of our land and were better skilled at a practical level. The indiscriminate use of today’s backhoe does more harm than good.

In the 1920’s a bridge was built at Macoucherie by local labour and, for the most part, with local materials. That bridge withstood the wrath of Erica and still stands where more recent bridges have failed. Without it there would now be no through vehicular route along the west coast. This begs the question: have we truly advanced?

I doubt that your grandparents would have declared Petite Savanne beyond recall. Rebuilding need not necessarily mean total relocation. True enough, some land will always remain untenable but other areas remain firm. An assessment has to be made to differentiate between the two. Moreover, land on the boarder-line needs to be stabilised. The planting of bamboo (a potential cash crop) and other fast growing soil-holding species should have begun over a year ago.

Last year the Prime Minister met with the people from Petite Savanne and deemed their village no longer safe. He is quoted as saying: The idea of this continuous debate of whether we should bring you back to Petite Savanne or not; c’mon; we don’t have to get an expert to tell us that the place is unsafe.* With respect, I firmly believe that the debate for some degree of re-settlement should be kept on the agenda.

On the other hand, I agree that retaining walls are no protection against the wrath of a storm like Erika. A sounder line of defense is better land management and an allowance for rivers to maintain their natural course. The construction of paved roads without sufficient attention to drainage is another destabilising factor.

I can well understand the frustration that prompted a DNO reader to write: I just can’t wait to be back with my own people. But a village is more than just people. It is the individuality of places that determines the individuality of ourselves. All too often the completed project on the ground has no resemblance to the artist’s pie-in-the-sky impression.

The Baroness said at the launching ceremony that, together we will do something quite extraordinary which has never been seen before. Let me assure the Baroness that the extraordinary and together components have certainly been seen before. Previously, they were not dependent on visiting missions, consultants and experts: they were a part of Dominica’s heritage.

Links to the cited DNO Commentaries are as follows:

https://dominicanewsonline.com/news/?s=culture+made+visible

COMMENTARY: Building back differently

COMMENTARY: Relocating a rural community to a town setting

COMMENTARY: Enabling a built environment

*The Chronicle, 2nd September 2016

The illustration shows the 1/12th scale maquette of Roger Burnett’s sculpture that commemorates the families displaced in Tropical Storm Erica. The figures represent the conflict of emotions experienced in being torn from the past:

Father with arm around his wife leading the family to the future.

Mother with babe in arms and head resting on her husband’s shoulder.

Grandmother sat with possessions looking back to what they are leaving behind.

Child (son) tugging father forward.

Child (daughter) clinging to father’s legs.

Disclaimer: The comments on this page do not necessarily reflect the views of DominicaNewsOnline.com/Duravision Inc. All comments are approved by DominicaNewsOnline.com before they are posted. We never censor based on political or ideological points of view, but we do try to maintain a sensible balance between free speech and responsible moderating.

We will delete comments that:

  • violate or infringe the rights of any person, are defamatory or harassing or include personal attacks
  • a reasonable person would consider abusive or profane
  • contain material which violates or encourages others to violate any applicable law
  • promote hatred of any kind
  • refer to people arrested or charged with a crime as though they had been found guilty
  • contain links to "chain letters", pornographic or obscene movies or graphic images
  • are excessively long and off-topic

See our full comment/user policy/agreement.

5 Comments

  1. A Wise Commentary
    March 30, 2017

    Roger Burnette thanks for the wisdom shared. Your insight is most worthy as it speaks to our heritage of intelligent action and pride in ourselves. The current environment on Dominica and its leadership is more given to anti intellectual barbarism and political victimization.

    We are doomed unless we change the habit of dismissing our own sense of innovation and native intelligence. The attack on Doninicans like Drs Sam Christian and Dale Dangleben proves the regime hates honest people who are Dominican.

  2. Spike
    March 30, 2017

    Mr. Burnett asks, “Have we truly advanced?” And foreign readers read and reply the same day, without postage stamps. Of course we have advanced! No, we have not gained dominance over nature or death. The old bridges were solid–though still not forever. Bailey bridges like the one that washed out are pre-fab and can be set up by a small crew in a day. They aren’t permanent either, but that is not the only criterion. Spend more time planning–driven by fallacies that wiser planting can resist nature, or even that rivers have a “natural course” that a storm cannot alter–and we will still not prevent or even anticipate future mishaps. Don’t abandon a town but note that different lands have a different cost to maintain after disasters with different likelihood, and arrange things so the individual can decide whether he wants to bear that cost, or can pay for insurance for someone else to bear the cost.

    • Clergy Man
      April 1, 2017

      Duh, English please :-x

  3. Erasmus B. Black
    March 30, 2017

    While we’re on the topic of salt, in the Holy Gospel of Luke (17) the Lord cryptically says to us ” Remember Lot’s wife.” Everyone though that Lot’s wife was this upright and upstanding woman. She professed true religion, had wealth, and enjoyed huge social privileges. But her heart was corrupt and she closed her eyes to the evil and wickedness of the leaders of her community of Sodom and Gomorrah. She was turned into a pillar or salt.

    May we also ponder on Lot’s wife and the pillar of salt this April Fools Day. Thank you Mr Burnett for the commentary.

  4. Titiwi
    March 30, 2017

    Roger, that is powerful and to the point. This no time for grandstanding and ego trips. We must face reality and rebuild the country that we all profess to love. To make it a beacon for all to see as an example to follow and a truly desirable place to dwell. I thank you for your thoughtful reflection, which gives me hope, strength and encouragement not to give up..

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

:) :-D :wink: :( 8-O :lol: :-| :cry: 8) :-? :-P :-x :?: :oops: :twisted: :mrgreen: more »

 characters available