COMMENTARY: Science and Public Policy in Dominica

EDITOR’s NOTE: As we celebrate the 40th anniversary of our Independence, DNO, in collaboration with the Dominica Academy of Arts and Sciences (DAAS), presents a series of interesting and relevant articles. The following article by Resource Economics and Planning Specialist and DAAS member, Dr. Davison Shillingford, was first published in May, 2006.

The recent Basil Springer article, SCIENCE AND PUBLIC POLICY, in the Barbados Advocate of May 1, 2006, raised an important issue. Especially significant for Dominica were two paragraphs, reprinted here, and their implication for some of the concerns currently facing the island.

Dr. Springer states, “Effective public policy depends on good science and good scientists, but in practice scientists, including statisticians, play only a limited role in the formulation of public policy.”

“A casual and ad hoc approach is an inefficient and incomplete way to deal with the range of scientific issues of national and international interest. Each nation should implement a mechanism to deal specifically with scientific issues at the highest level. Particulars will differ according to each nation’s interests, resources and political
organization, but each such plan will need to address the issues raised here.”

The advances taking place in Dominica or those in the pipeline – the fisheries complex at Marigot, the Carib Village, the PetroCarib deal, the stadium, the airport extension, the increase in cruise ship visits, quality control in tourist services, high quality carnival celebration, the planned improvements in the Portsmouth and airport roads, among others – are significant, and government must be commended for this progress. However, the list of issues currently facing the island remains substantial. And if we are to make the rapid economic gains required, we need to address these issues urgently and systematically.

The issues include – education and economic development, jobs, the functioning of the Dominica College, the DOMLEC monopoly and energy policy, banana productivity and agricultural policy, inter-island produce transport, global warming and the crapaud problem, Botanic Gardens redevelopment, bigger berths for cruise ships, traffic
congestion and the parking problem in Roseau, the medical implications of current migration to Dominica, the adequacy of medical services in general, Diaspora policy, crime and the judiciary, the Aves Island issue, the Avian flu pandemic, among others.

There are three points to be made about this list: (i) these are mostly normal issues for the average developing country, (ii) we can live with them almost indefinitely but the quality of life will be low and the result will be mass migration, and (iii) we can resolve these issues with a little effort. However, we cannot solve this multitude of issues
piecemeal and haphazardly. It would take 100 years. We can only do it systematically.

These critical national issues arise and we have no national mechanism/body with the mandate and authority to deal with them with the urgency that they deserve, since government is taking care of the even more urgent day to day business of running the country. The US has the National Science Foundation, Barbados: the National Council
for Science, Jamaica, Trinidad, and almost every other country, recognising the critical nature of the issue, have such a foundation. These are not the window dressing of independence. They are the essentials of successful nation building and national self-interest. They are primarily concerned with issues, which, while urgent, might be put on a
back burner and not addressed until it is too late; and then these issues become fatal.

Dominica urgently needs a similar council/foundation. The issue is not to usurp the responsibilities of government ministries, but to complement them in the policy development arena at the highest level, while the ministries go about the business of policy implementation. The presence of all of these problems and issues is testimony to the urgent need for an institution tasked with finding solutions. And the object is not to get a series of councils, one for each technical area. We are too small a country for that. We need one properly constituted council with the
mandate to mobilise the technical competences from various fields, set up in subcommittees, whose tasks are to make Dominica work optimally, multitask its problem solving, create a dynamic, job-generating economy, and put the island ahead of the economic game, despite its small size.

A Dominican friend of mine once recounted that after he had made a presentation to his company executives with several original ideas on how his company can beat the competition, one executive, impressed with my friend’s insight and strategies, came to his office and inquired where he was from. He said Dominica and showed the exec the
tiny island on a world map. My friend says, the exec in surprise blurted, “You mean you come from a small island like that !!!!!”

The point is sound and significant ideas do not need to have their genesis in big countries, or foreign countries for that matter. They are available right here at home or among our people abroad. Our welfare lies in our capacity to effectively mobilize our own people and their intellect here in Dominica (or abroad) to solve our problems, despite our small size. The establishment of a comprehensive national council on science and public policy will be a major step in securing that objective and Dominican economic growth. Such an institution is urgently needed in Dominica. Its composition is fairly straightforward and more a matter of detail.

In the past, the Colonial Office played that policy role for us; and we have done without an effective replacement since independence. But as the UK has disengaged and distanced itself from us, the vacuum here is becoming more apparent, as evidenced in the long but partial list of policy issues above and their growing urgency. We desperately
need to fill that vacuum with a dynamic local organization. Without such a nationally focused organization to sort out and resolve national issues, and provide advice for government action, economic growth and job creation will be slow, encouraging continued mass migration.

Disclaimer: The comments on this page do not necessarily reflect the views of Inc. All comments are approved by before they are posted. We never censor based on political or ideological points of view, but we do try to maintain a sensible balance between free speech and responsible moderating.

We will delete comments that:

  • violate or infringe the rights of any person, are defamatory or harassing or include personal attacks
  • are abusive, profane or offensive
  • contain material which violates or encourages others to violate any applicable law
  • promote hatred of any kind
  • refer to people arrested or charged with a crime as though they had been found guilty
  • contain links to "chain letters", pornographic or obscene movies or graphic images
  • are excessively long and off-message

See our full comment/user policy/agreement.


  1. My name
    October 31, 2018

    This Government will not listen or take advise. Worst Administration ever. They just have to get out no other way. It’s time.

  2. Dr Clayton Shillingford
    October 31, 2018

    Here is an opportunity for Dominica and its people to guide the ship of state with different more progressive thinking and actions.. Let us hope any Dominican Government will take heed to utilize all the Dominican talent that is available locally and in the Diaspora Thanks Dave
    We should revisit the DAAS Diaspora policy guidelines. The attached commentary by others is also pertinent to finding effective solutions.. Propaganda and lies by some actors will not get us to where we ought to be as a nation..We need to get away from this…”We thrive on gossip (Bef), and we have cultivated a fete (Sewo) culture. We have become laid back and our leaders have sensed our weakness and they have taken advantage of that”

  3. anonymous2
    October 30, 2018

    Unfortunately science has also become a religion. There is too much false science.

  4. viewsexpressed
    October 30, 2018

    Looking, I thank you for your valid response, I also must thank the DAAS community for its usual professional commentary and education on matters of Public Policy and implementation.
    It is sad to say that we do not have the necessary competent people as the Government to run this country of ours. Eighteen ministers lead by someone who has failed over 18 years is not going to get us and Dominica anywhere in the next 18 years. I am serious about this and they must go, they have failed big Time.
    There is no development taking place in Domininca. It is just talk by PM, saying nothing but enjoys the flamboyant event of the presence of a visiting PM, or I have met this person etc. His fans seems to go hay wire on this. I`ve seen it and you ask what was purpose of this meeting or travel to you and Domininca, but unable to understand. This is the biggest Soap Opera taking place in the Caribbean. PM, must get his script from the Young and Restless, his acting obviously is fatal, a gimmick.

    • Looking
      October 30, 2018

      Thanks, Viewsexpressed, but unfortunately we should not only blame our leaders but our populace. We thrive on gossip (Bef), and we have cultivated a fete (Sewo) culture. We have become laid back and our leaders have sensed our weakness and they have taken advantage of that. Our women are weak and vulnerable and our men castrated. Greed reigns supreme. How can one be happy if one’s neighbour’s house is uncovered? How can one be at peace knowing that people are victimized for their political or religious affiliation? Someone please explain this to me. So Sewo we like, we get Sewo, Bef we like we get Bef.

  5. Looking
    October 30, 2018

    “Dominica urgently needs a similar council/foundation. The issue is not to usurp the responsibilities of government ministries, but to complement them in the policy development arena at the highest level, while the ministries go about the business of policy implementation.” – This is way beyond the abilities and capabilities of our present ministers and i don’t see this happening anytime soon. We have accepted, normalized and standardized mediocrity. Dominica presently, is being run like a plantation with its Ruler calling the “shots” on virtually everything, sadly, to the detriment of future generations. As many would say, Dominica is not a real country.

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

:) :-D :wink: :( 8-O :lol: :-| :cry: 8) :-? :-P :-x :?: :oops: :twisted: :mrgreen: more »

 characters available