UPDATE WITH LETTER: ‘Derose’ management team goes after Patrick Pemberton

Derose. Photo by Zaimis Olmos

The management team of 2013 calypso finalist Dexter “Derose” Peltier, has asked well-known calypso judge, Patrick Pemberton, to exclude himself from the judging panel of the 2013 calypso finals.

Pemberton was a guest recently on privately-owned Kairi FM where he reportedly criticized Derose’s song.

This is not going down well with the calypsonian’s management team who made its position known in a letter from the law firm of Joshua Francis to Pemberton and copied to president of the Dominica Calypso Association (DCA), Kelly Williams, and co-ordinator of judges, Ferdina Frampton.

According to the letter, Pemberton said on the show, “I remember that there was a line in the song before Scrunter that said a calypsonian was paid….”

Pemberton has until ‘Midday on Thursday 7 2013’ to respond or legal action will be taken against him, the letter stated.

“Our clients are of the opinion that you exhibited poor taste and unprofessionalism in appearing on the afore-mentioned radio talk show, hence raising issues of conflict of interest and putting into disrepute your role as a Judge of the DCA 2013 Calypso Finals,” the letter states.

It continues: “In view of the above, we have been instructed to make it abundantly clear to you that your decision to make certain comments on the said show has raised the possibility of your favoritism and bias as a Judge for the 2013 Calypso Finals.  Our clients are of the opinion that you will not dispose a fair treatment to ‘Derose’ at the DCA 2013 Calypso Finals because of your expressed ‘personal bias,’ ‘and prejudice’ against “Derose” and ‘conflict of interest’ in the public arena.”

The letter stated that the position of Pemberton “as a judge” has become “untenable” and that in the interest of the integrity of the DCA 2013 Calypso Finals, he should recuse himself.

“In the circumstances, we respectfully ask you to consider the ongoing controversies which have mired the Calypso season thus far, and in the interest of the integrity of calypso and calypso lovers, you would behave impeccably and cure your action which appears to have tarnished your reputation as a Chief Judge by relinquishing your role as a Judge in the said show. Should you fail to respond favourably by Midday on Thursday Feb 7, 2013, we have been instructed to consider the appropriate legal action to settle this matter,” the letter stated.

Derose is known for his song this year, “Ba Yo Babalen.”

See full letter below.

Copyright 2012 Dominica News Online, DURAVISION INC. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or distributed.

Disclaimer: The comments posted do not necessarily reflect the views of DominicaNewsOnline.com and its parent company or any individual staff member. All comments are posted subject to approval by DominicaNewsOnline.com. We never censor based on political or ideological points of view, but we do try to maintain a sensible balance between free speech and responsible moderating.

We will delete comments that:

  • contain any material which violates or infringes the rights of any person, are defamatory or harassing or are purely ad hominem attacks
  • a reasonable person would consider abusive or profane
  • contain material which violates or encourages others to violate any applicable law
  • promote prejudice or prejudicial hatred of any kind
  • refer to people arrested or charged with a crime as though they had been found guilty
  • contain links to "chain letters", pornographic or obscene movies or graphic images
  • are off-topic and/or excessively long

See our full comment/user policy/agreement.

144 Comments

  1. Haunted
    February 6, 2013

    hunter who? :lol:

  2. Stupes
    February 6, 2013

    The crux of the matter is TOOOOOOOOOOOOO much POLITICS and POLITICAL VICTIMIZATION in the country!!!! Time for Ash Wednesday to come!

  3. just saying
    February 6, 2013

    Calypso today is much too political for my liking. at least if a calypso song is well put together I don’t mind, but some are just political garbage.

    • Anonymous
      February 6, 2013

      Your mind is the garbage not the calypso. Go reform your mind SOT!

  4. Unique
    February 6, 2013

    Now supposing …Pemberton had not expressed his opinion of Delroses’s song…would Matt and Delrose know if Pemberton liked or did not like the song?…What about other judges that may dislike the song and have not said anything?…Delrose and his management are just being silly

  5. an observer
    February 6, 2013

    as bob said in his song, we have to make a way, to put all this nonsense aside and build our beautiful dominica. young bull also sang talk nor, talk nor, is just palee palee but the country is still moving. one day the same ones that always causing a roro, will ask for peace, when they will be cut in some act and ask for peace. make my words, some dominicans just see with one eye.

    • Lang Doug
      February 6, 2013

      @ an observer

      That’s got nothing to do with blue, red or green but with ethics and priciples. So go bury your gutter politics in the labasse.

  6. I sometimes Wonder
    February 6, 2013

    Pembo, you must be feeling betrayed when you consider your fellow blues are so quick to malign you for a simple comment. Now you must be asking what have i done to deserve that pressure. Sorry partner feel your squeeze. Skerrit gets it 24 7 sometimes from you. Take what you get

    • ..................
      February 6, 2013

      Why won’t you Go To Hell! Go to Hell! Go to Hell! with your political crap.

      • Just Looking On
        February 7, 2013

        Is that all you can say? What a childish way to behave. If you have nothing better to say, I think you should refrain from commenting via this medium. Its really unbecoming of an adult, which I hope you are! Please, enough of this ok. Have a blessed day.

  7. Anonymous
    February 6, 2013

    Poor Dominica. In Dominica everyting goes these days, no ethics, no morality, no integrity. It is not what bad deed is done, it is who does it. Some people can do no wrong in the eyes of too many of the Dominican puplic.

  8. February 6, 2013

    They REAL burning you.

  9. Anonymous
    February 6, 2013

    Whether he may be able to put aside his obvious bias on the night of the show doesn’t even matter at this point. He may be able to rise above and judge fairly at the show but the fact that there is an appearance of bias is the issue at this point. He should not have made the statement that he made and the fact that he did means that he should not be judging the show.

  10. Seriously
    February 6, 2013

    Seriously ? Whatever ever happened to the fun of calypso. It is getting too serious..People analyse the calypsos all the time and as a judge he has the right to JUDGE the song. Derose should take the judge’s advice. This is just stupid and those lawyers more soutiweh. Not like Derose could win anyway.

    • Anonymous
      February 6, 2013

      You consider 20,000 a joke? People kill for a dollar farless 20,000.

  11. This is ignoranct ta
    February 6, 2013

    Are we saying that because Pembo made the comment that he is bias towards Derose and that the other judges who did not make comments are not bias at all? Our socialization, circumstances, environment, religion, level of knowledge etc makes us implicitly bias to one topic, subject or another even to a race and a nationality. And that implicit bias can affect the way people evaluate a job candidate or as in our case judge a calyposnian.

    Regardless of what Pembo said or did not say there is always a level of implicit bias as an individual and by extension as a judge. So what is all that hue and cry about? We really idle in this country, making controversy about everything and nothing. Please my people get real.

    • MJ
      February 6, 2013

      Yes Pembo is being biased and the comment you made about the other judges is rather ridiculous. If the other judges are bias, we do not know because they did not go on the air and publicly announce it but Pembo did. So he needs to step down!

  12. Toomatoe Tomato
    February 6, 2013

    I feel for the Dominica public who truly enjoy Carnival and enjoy going to the shows –

    Or does it really have anything to do with carnival? Or is there something much more sinister happening?

    The question is what? And Why?

  13. It matters
    February 6, 2013

    So your brother uses the air ways to incite controversy to get rid of another calypsonian, DONE ! now he is on his quest to get rid of the chief judge, PENDING. Why stop there! why not simple just eliminate all opposition to his “CROWN”. WHO NEXT.

  14. Can't Believe this
    February 6, 2013

    Every week is a new attack. Last week was hunter and ghost this week is Pembo. I would advice Pembo to ignore the double standard individuals on Q95. They make all sorts of accusations/comments about people but they can’t take one little criticism.

    These guys will shut up one of those day. Just wait.

  15. hart brooks
    February 6, 2013

    After reading this letter from the lawer i think the judge should not judge the finals this year.but i would suggest that we have a new set of judges for eliminations/ quarters/ semis/ and the finals i think we will get better results during the season and less row- row.i think the judges we have now are to comfortable and there mind are set as to who they want to be king.please don’t kill calypso it is sweeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeet.

  16. Peeping Tom
    February 6, 2013

    I did not hear the Linton show and so I cannot give an opinion on the above quote, supposedly from Mr. Pemberton, without first understanding the context in which it was made.

    I did, however, hear part of Matt’s “Hot Seat” show in which he replayed a recording from Mr. Linton’s show on the weekend past. It seems Mr. Linton had discussed the Pemberton affair and was very suggestive to the Derose management that it should act.

    I find it highly ironic and utterly reprehensible that Mr. Linton, would now cry «bias» and “prejudice” and suggesting to Matt, the said manager of the calysonian, to act against Mr. Pemberton. Let us recall …

    1. Mr. Linton does not think that the IPO Commission is tainted and biased against the PM although he knows that it contains some of the most ardent critics and, some would say, enemies, of the PM. In fact, in his eyes, this Commission is good enough to «judge» the PM.
    2. Mr. Linton sees no evil in his public use of information that was leaked from the Commission, in flagrant contravention of Section 21 (1) and (4) of the IPO Act. The immediate effect of this leak is to hijack the process by implanting biased opinions, inferences, and suppositions in the minds of the public and whichever Commissioner cared to listen.

    Yet, Mr, Linton, at least publicly, cannot see the bias against the PM that is entrenched in this present process. However, he quickly sees bias and prejudice in Mr. Pemberton’s statement. Mr. Linton is in no moral position to point that finger. He claims to speak for integrity and all those warm fuzzy concepts, but here he is publicly showing that his understanding of “truth, justice, and integrity” is warped; twisted, even! Are his double-standard and hypocrisy (I am being kind here) the type of integrity that he wishes for Dominicans?

    I suppose an act is fair or just depending on who does it, and a patriot is a “patriot” depending on which side of the fence he sits. Like I always said, Mr. Linton’s definition of justice does not extend beyond justice for himself and his associates. I will now add, that his vision of justice indeed CANNOT extend beyond himself and his cartel. One day I will tell you more about this extension.

    Meanwhile, happy and safe carnival to all!

    • Peeping Tom
      February 6, 2013

      “I did not hear the Linton show and so I cannot give an opinion on the above quote, supposedly from Mr. Pemberton, without first understanding the context in which it was made.”

      This should have read, “I did not hear the Kairi show….”

      • Choice - X
        February 6, 2013

        u seem to chose what you hear. This is not a linton affair, so keep linton out of your marjee.

      • Anonymous
        February 6, 2013

        ohh was wondering about that

    • It matters
      February 6, 2013

      They are the Pharisee & Scribes of our times.

    • MJ
      February 6, 2013

      I am so sick of Linton himself..D man always finding fault with ppl and not looking at himself

  17. February 6, 2013

    Hello sweet Dominica. Well based on what I read in this article I must agree that the judge should step down. He can no longer be fair to the contestant after he criticize his song or even if the judge feel that he can be fair . He must still recuse himself because he already pass judgement on the contestant song although the contest has not been held. So Mr Pemberton please do the right thing otherwise DCA will have to suspend you from judging the competition. Mr Pemberton you placed your self in this situation and you should have known better because you are task with being impartial as a judge.

    • tim
      February 6, 2013

      yup, no boubt

  18. Stuffy
    February 5, 2013

    As forma calypsonian I think this is to much. I think we need to start cleaning up from the top. President and the executive. They need to go.

  19. vexness
    February 5, 2013

    Boy calypso need blabalen this year…to much rowrow, doh matter how small d comment, judge suppose 2 stay silent, run ur mouth afterr d show.

  20. Justice and Truth
    February 5, 2013

    Words from an old calypso, a good one which came to my mind:

    Mi miser.
    Sa pou faire.
    You must fight for your right.
    Let them know that this is no one man show. :)

    Some of you who are old enough will remember the words of this calypso in bygone years. It rings true today.
    I do not recall there were such controversies in those years. Well, we only had one Radio Station, DBS; no TV and computer. Dominicans then were more interested in enjoying carnival and we did.

  21. legal eagle
    February 5, 2013

    @DNO
    Your headline …”‘Derose’ management team goes after Patrick Pemberton..” sounds very aggressive and makes it appear that Derose and company are a vicious lynch mob. Is there any way you could taper down this approach?

  22. cornmeal
    February 5, 2013

    As a calypsonian who made it to the finals, if a judge would criticise my song i would look on the positive side and make the necessary changes. Change the line!!!! Fix the song, make it good. Stop all this negative vibes and grow up. I know of judges who have spoken to calypsonians about their songs to try to get them to improve on it and guess what, they turn around and hate the judges.

  23. Jina
    February 5, 2013

    who tell them take calypso and bring down so low.

  24. upset
    February 5, 2013

    matt is a trouble maker

  25. eyes
    February 5, 2013

    Are they paying the judges and how much

  26. as i see
    February 5, 2013

    i hear they fraid, oh yes they fraid they fraid. well my boys just get rid of all the judges and all the contenders because that’s the only way your people will win the crown! how sad…………

  27. listening
    February 5, 2013

    Mr. pemperton said calypsonians must know what they are saying when sing. he said to say a calysonian was paid to sing a certain song,that singing is implecating that the other received monies and that could be bad. its only that line. dominicans are really something else. delrose could say that in his song, but scrunter could not say is follow fire that burn his place. we are to bias in this place. as some rightly say, is who say it. if it was another calypsonian, in would be something else. Mr. pemberton is long they want you to leave, so just leave the judging for q95 to judge, because we now how the result would be anyway. onnce you not singing about skerrit and the dlp out you go. i know the dumbs down will out my light, but that is ok. DNO, try to do better than that next time. get the audio of mr pembo and let everone hear the question and his answer on kiari.

  28. rescue 911
    February 5, 2013

    hunter bow now u bow.

  29. PERPLEXED
    February 5, 2013

    WILL THE CALYPSO COMPETITION SOON BECOME A THING OF THE PAST?

  30. cod capi
    February 5, 2013

    lets go dominicans let the investigative journalist kill all what they see can bring an income for dominica. the same pembo made you reach the finals, melody and basic words its time we flush these investagative jounalist in the pit toilet

  31. Corrupt_Bastards
    February 5, 2013

    So what if pembo dislike the song, this is nonsense now.

  32. Righteous
    February 5, 2013

    These need to to be left out of calypso. The art form is being ridicule by these who are only seeking attention.

  33. Dominican
    February 5, 2013

    How many of y’all go to judges workshop? but those who sacrifice themselves to the art to save calypso are being boooed also. Matt, lenox,derose and all d other haters at a particular radio station will have to examine themselves and let LOVE & PEACE continue in our country.

  34. MIA
    February 5, 2013

    Garcon, mi barb pou rose !! Eh-ben look it!! :lol:

  35. Kaiso Fan
    February 5, 2013

    If Pembo was speaking in the capacity of a calypso judge then he should definitely exclude himself from the finals. You cannot be a judge and be on radio saying anything negative about a calypsonian song. Pembo thats a No No. Deros and his crew are right on Q.

  36. james
    February 5, 2013

    Whats wrong with some people in Dominica? can we just get on. PLEASE. Derose look at those arround you.

  37. Purveyor of truth???
    February 5, 2013

    Lennox is the biggest sower of seeds of discord in DA; I listened to him on Sunday as
    he stripped Hunter, Ras Kelly and Pembo. I heard the sound bite as it pertains to Pembo, Pembo was responding to a statement made by Kelly that the line in Derose’s song about a calypsonian being paid to sing the anti-GON song maybe libelous. Kelly was struggling to find the word and Pembo gave him the word. I am sure most of you here never heard the interview. Lennox pushed and pulled the issue and here you have it Pembo is being burned at the stake. Lennox is doing as if his kith and kin have no maypwe or dirty linen..those of us who went to Goodwill School in the 70s have some very unsavoury stories to tell…he better go and console his dying father and stop picking fights with everybody; give another man a chance. Careful what you wish for.

    • Anonymous
      February 6, 2013

      what matt father have to do with you? ppl like u does upset me

  38. Former Calypso Judge
    February 5, 2013

    First and formost let me say that it waqs the same Pemberton that was on the pannel that Derose got in to the finals .if i had been a judge he would not be there full stop and the only thing that got him there as the candles that were lit on the grounds and some of the judges took that as a form of presentation and aawarded him ppoints for that.Secondly the so called LYRICS is very poor,i see nothing wrong in Pemberton talking about what he thinks as inflammatory in the ensuing sentence.As a former judge i have personnaly called on a few calypsonians and told them where they had gone wrong ,I can make mention of Sye,Hunter Scrunter ,Checker to name a few,and that they were very happy about it ,The media has caused Hunter to withdraw from this years competition and in the very same week he won the Police Calypso King Competition,with the same song i think,If i do know this gentleman i do not think this is going to worry him at all. Calypso and Calypsonians are judged only on the night that they present and performntheir songs on the night of the performances,it was the same chief judge that judged him from scratch to where he is at the present why no one ever sain that he was to step down.Lyrics are Lyrics and then after Scrunter Sang he was Booooood and the radio talk show s never comented about that if they did it was in support of the crowd Pemberton is already rescued so i do not know why he has to rescue himself anymore.
    come on Dominican’s stop playing and putting politics into our calypsoes which was the brainchild of the Q95 so called Journalists it was one of the very same Journalists some years ago that some people had ramsacked his vehicle after a calypso finals .let the calypso move on and to the Seven (7)finalists from the StarDom Tent i say good luck to you guys
    AND A HAPPY CARNIVAL TO ALL OF DOMINICANS.

    • MJ
      February 6, 2013

      As a former Judge, I think you are being ridiculous. Pembo should refrain from any negative comments publicly until after he has judged the finals. Why should he be on the air bringing down the calypsonian.

      It is a conflict of interest. What he did displayed pure biasness for Derose. It shows exactly how he will judge the night, which is UNFAIR!!!!

  39. LA PWTE
    February 5, 2013

    We standing behind Derose. That is the first time we have a contender in the calypso finals, so don’t mess with our boy. We are so proud of you Derose. Don’t back down; stand up for your rights.

  40. midnight dare
    February 5, 2013

    once you are a judge, you cannot go publicly experiencing your opinion on any song. i dont know who is pembo and dont want to know who he is but as a Judge he should keep his opinions for himself.

    • yesa
      February 6, 2013

      but is true.you should not go on any media and say what you think and don’t think about people’s song.unproffesionalism

  41. The Authorities
    February 5, 2013

    @Admin:

    The date to respond according to the “legal” document is “by Midday on Thursday 7, 2013”

    Nowhere did it state a month (like you did).

    Mr. Pemberton’s attorney can therefore instruct him to ignore this document.

    • Lawyer
      February 5, 2013

      good eye

    • giraudel
      February 5, 2013

      good catch

    • :)
      February 6, 2013

      is there calypso finals in any other month in 2013??

      • The Authorities
        February 6, 2013

        As far as we know, that may be true, but a good lawyer can debate that this still remains an assumption, thereby introducing the frivolity defence.

        Frivolous litigation consists of a claim or defense that is presented where the party (or the party’s legal counsel) had reason to know that the claim or defense was manifestly insufficient or futile.

  42. Anonymous
    February 5, 2013

    What if Pembo was speaking the view of the other judges as well? It could be a risk to ask him out when the others may take offence and right him off.

  43. I sometimes Wonder
    February 5, 2013

    If Matt and his crew would ever get the chance to control Dominica heaven help our souls… if a person cannot criticize a calypsonian, when they come Minister of Information they would close down all radio stations…. These people are so petty and foolish. I have never seen calypso reach that low because of all that roro.. Man allyou killing the art form. Booing Scrunter was ok, booing Beno last year was fine, Hunting down hunter is fine but just saying Derose had similar lines to someone else is a national crime.
    Derose you must make style because i cannot see how you reach finals eh…. Just because candle burn….. You can never get crown? In your dreams
    ;

    • __________________
      February 5, 2013

      @ I sometimes wonder: You have been an unrepentant supporter of evil and corruption for so long, that whenever you don’t like something honest people must cling unto it, because it must be good.
      Go drink a dose of decency,morality, integrity,uprightness and stop you support for wrongful acts.
      It’s people like you that have failed the country and cause it to be languishing as one of the poorest in the region.

    • February 5, 2013

      obviously a judge of the calypso show caanot publicly critize a calypso. think dominican think. let me put it in basic terms, if you are going up for a queen show or some paegent and u overhear a judge say you are too ugly to be in the competition. would you want that judge to be in the panel of judges assessing you. obviously that judge will be bias because he has already said you are ugly. just an example to try to make u understand, then again if u are blinded then…..

    • stupes!
      February 5, 2013

      what r u talking about? similar lines????

    • Anonymous
      February 5, 2013

      @sometimeswonder deros tell u he want crown.stuppsssss!

      • Truth
        February 6, 2013

        So what he competing for? :mrgreen:

    • Anonymous
      February 5, 2013

      I don’t know what is funnier, that comment itself or the 10+ people who liked it. Smh

    • calypso fan
      February 5, 2013

      Up he up bcuz he never thought he would reach finals with his song that is so disjointed, If Mr Pemberton had anything personal against him and his song he would not have made it, furthermore there was a three way tie which included him and he was sent in as first choice, so I don’t see any need for that.Calypso has been there for so long and those “just comes” think they can just come in and create controversy. Tell Derose and his brother Matt will and come again.

    • Justice and Truth
      February 5, 2013

      Heaven help us bodily, physically, emotionally and financially.
      Souls are for God to deal with; not human beings. :)

    • Brathwait
      February 6, 2013

      You must listen and understand the discussion. It’s evident that you are ignorant of the facts or is it that you lack understanding.

  44. IPO
    February 5, 2013

    So Matt and dem fellas have become judge, jury and executioner in Dominica…

    Note: The more you judge the more you hate

    • wannaknowso he haves
      February 5, 2013

      so he had a right to go on the show say all he had toand no1 would question his motive,eh…you to bi-ass

    • ....................
      February 5, 2013

      @ IPO You are so darn moronic in what you are writing you must be referring to yourself and you are ignorant of it…All Night schools are opened.

      • IPO
        February 5, 2013

        Yep

    • Not a herd follower
      February 5, 2013

      Did Matt put words in Pembo’s mouth?

    • IPO
      February 5, 2013

      IPO you damm rude tell Pembo go seat somehere …his Daddy Matt has shut him up…if is me that is Daddy Miller I suing Pembo becuase his song is way way better than babalen…how could Pembo even make Babalen go befor illegal king? What a travesty…alas

      So Pembo Matt do well shutting you up and IPO be quiet

  45. nora
    February 5, 2013

    Pembo is a great judge, leave the man alone!! If he judges the finals and Derose were to become king, would derose give up the crown because a bias judge was on the panel?.. that is left to be seen…When you sue pembo, is the calypso association that have to pay all the fees,,, Deros, less money for you.

    • Brathwait
      February 6, 2013

      Stand for what’s right, it’s not about who gets more or less money. where is your moral standing.

    • Stupes
      February 6, 2013

      Nora your key word is IF and you are speaking in the future… so in the meantime, Pembo wrong!

  46. Ovaltine
    February 5, 2013

    The judges should be different every year. They cannot have the same judges every year and do not expect such things to go on.

    New Judges I say. Out with the old, in with some new.

    • February 5, 2013

      Yes every year their should be new judges and maybe they should be from other parts of the region because their are too many issues around in place folks are too touchy.

      • Anonymous
        February 6, 2013

        I disagree with that view, especially the part about foreign judges. The judge should be able to identify with the issues/messages in the songs, something which a foreigner will find difficult. Would a judge from trini know for example what caressar is talking about in his song?

  47. Drlee
    February 5, 2013

    I have alot of respect for mr. Pemberton, I think he is a man that many in Dominica can look up to, but considering what was said he is not qualified to be a judge at this year’s Calypso finals.

  48. Sweet Dominica
    February 5, 2013

    But Pembo was a judge at the semi finals and Delrose made it to the finals.I’m sure Pembo had the same view on the calypso at the time. Delrose you made it to the finals, the furthest you can reach. Crown? No way.

    • bias dcans
      February 5, 2013

      what mske y think he was in favor of this calypsonian…he was not the only judge

      • This is ignoranct ta
        February 6, 2013

        Even if he is not for Derose, is he going to be the only judge at the finals?

    • Look me!
      February 5, 2013

      Pembo is just one judge. And as head judge in the even there is a tie, he casts the “make or break” vote. Go figure.

  49. computer
    February 5, 2013

    calypso association better start looking for their new software…..otherwise long hours from pen and paper calculation…….leave pembo alone eh

  50. Fan
    February 5, 2013

    Best DCA cancel the Calypso show wi, cause before Saturday night, they will find another issue to cry about. I have never seen Calypso in so much controversy. Never has it been to that extreme before. Its ridiculous!! I have no taste for Calypso again.

    But on the other hand Mr Pemberton you self should never put yourself in that situation to accept the invitation from Kamala to come on her show to discuss Calypso Semi Finals. As chief judge you have no analysing to do with Kamala Jno Baptiste Aaron or for anybody for that matter!!!!!!

  51. North Passie
    February 5, 2013

    What good for the goose is good for the ganda. Mr Pemberton has nothing to do. DeRose enter finals by a floops, man go sing for your supper and go and jump up eh because is your first and last time in finals. He and his Q95 crew can say what they want on their radio and no other person should talk? Nonesense.WICKED PEOPLE

    • T
      February 5, 2013

      @North Passie Q95 is the perfect antidote to drive anger and jealousy away… Here resides the best journalists Dominica has to offer.
      Wonderful sons of the soil they all are… I LOVE THEM! DO YOU?

    • Lougaoo Mem
      February 5, 2013

      Such ignorance helps promotes the divisiveness that’s destroying the country today. How can one dignify him or herself with so much hate? It is disconcerting to say the least of the state of affairs in our little Dominica.

  52. Domerican/Possie
    February 5, 2013

    I heard the program and what Pemberton said was in very poor taste. As a judge he should know better than that.

  53. concern
    February 5, 2013

    Mr. Pemberton even if you thought that way about a Calypsoian, you dont say that in public as the CHIEF JUDGE. SHAME ON YOU! Please recuse yourself in the interest of CALYPSO.

  54. My2Sense
    February 5, 2013

    I don’t think he should have said that… given his position.

    But let’s not get it twisted – a personal opinion need not bias one’s professional conduct. For example, if I’m not mistaken, Pemberton served on both the Quarter Finals and Semi Finals judging panels, and Derose still made it to the finals.

    To me, it is then obvious that either the protocols set up for fair judging are working well (well enough to make it so that Pemberton’s “biases” do not keep back Derose) OR it could mean that Pemberton keeps his personal opinion at bay when he is judging.

    • Good p
      February 5, 2013

      OR, it could mean that the scores of the 5 or 6 other judges made up for whatever bias he may have held.

  55. Pathetic
    February 5, 2013

    There is o doubt that he has prejudiced his position as a chief judge ans should step down with immediate effect. I am rather surprise that Pembo would make such comments, taking into consideration his position. He has to go now!

    • Joe
      February 5, 2013

      So Pathetic what was his COMMENTS bon dieu!!!!!

      All of all you just PATHETIC about a comment a comment the man made but uptil now not even DNO can repeat the damn man comment……

      DNO can you ask the Lawyer to reveal the comment his client is so upset about, if not for anyone else do it for me PLEASE!!!

      The media must be balance and fair at all times, and right now is only one-side am seeing here!

      • Keeping hem Honest
        February 5, 2013

        According to the letter Pemberton said on the show, “I remember that there was a line in the song before Scrunter that said a calypsonian was paid….”

  56. Anonymous
    February 5, 2013

    I think we’re finally becoming alert and have begun the process in not ‘laying down’ so we can be taken advantage of. Many may view this as a ‘roro’ by DeRose who’s manager is his brother, Matt Peltier, most criticized talk show host on Q95. But calypso is big man thing, and is an even bigger money thing.

    We all have our favorites, and Mr. Pemberton is no exception as he too is human. It’s unfortunate he got caught up in the hype and took to air his views next to the anti – Mas Camp Ras Kelly on the anti Mas – Camp Kairi FM (who coincidentally doesn’t air songs from that said camp)

    As for the competition, DeRose chances are good as mine but you never know he might put on the performance of his life and elevate into the top four if the usual suspects (Dice, Karessah, Chess, or Bobb) fail to execute exceptionally.

    With that said, Mr Pemberton should kindly withdraw himself from the panel and if he fails to do so then the coordinator should do us the service. If that too fails, I’m sure the court (once not influenced) will make the right call. Anyway calypso must go on and no DeRose or no Pembo is going to stop us.

    Good luck all and please come out to support on Saturday (even if your show squeezing you)

  57. sandy
    February 5, 2013

    I tremble for Dominica and for many of us as true Dominicans when I reflect that God is just; that his justice cannot sleep over.

    Why can’t we do things right? Alas Father help us and help Dominica.

  58. Anonymous
    February 5, 2013

    Derose you do right. How does this man expect to be there and he on radio talking about your song ?

  59. choo
    February 5, 2013

    The Same judge that put him in the finals that made the statement. the man was just talking about a line in a song that may have been of poor taste because he dont know if they pay any calypsonian to sing a song about FOLLOW putting fire to his home. Knowing Pembo, if he was sked about scrunter song, he would say it was of poooooor taste to.

    • Not a herd follower
      February 5, 2013

      Pembo should not have made that comment given his position as a judge and Chief Judge at that! People must be mindful of the responsibilities and the expectations associated with their roles. If a magistrate had said of an accused who is to appear before him that he believes he is guilty on a radio programme, what would be our reaction?

  60. sugar
    February 5, 2013

    I agree with u Viewpoint lol woooosh

    • Anonymous
      February 5, 2013

      Way to go deros!stand up for your right!you don’t need their crown.some people just need to know their dam place.pembo should not be a judge on that night.nous Ka ba yo babalen day and night!hahhaha.who vex tuff!lol

  61. sugar
    February 5, 2013

    Allu don’t know what Pembo say so shut allu dam mouth

    • T
      February 5, 2013

      @ sugar Go To Hell! Go To Hell! Go to Hell! Go lock yourself in a toilet!

      • Anonymous
        February 5, 2013

        Or go fishing by the bay

      • Keeping hem Honest
        February 5, 2013

        HEHEHEHEHEHEHEHEHEEH

      • Keeping hem Honest
        February 5, 2013

        According to the letter Pemberton said on the show, “I remember that there was a line in the song before Scrunter that said a calypsonian was paid….”2

  62. Asking
    February 5, 2013

    Is this judge planning to victimize the calypsonians for his thoughts and opinions?

    Well judge you are also entitled to your thoughts and opinions about the song but you should recuse your self from judging ever again.

  63. TO JUDE NICHOLAS
    February 5, 2013

    One thing those three burning you papa.

    • Jude Nicholas
      February 5, 2013

      No they not burning me. You claim bias on the part of pembio but you want to have bias people on the IPOD.

  64. A Voice
    February 5, 2013

    If the judge did go on the air making disparaging remarks about the calypsonian, then he should go ahead and recuse himself.

    Definite bad judgement by the judge…if he is in fact guilty.

    BTW, what were his remarks nah?

  65. Tax Payer
    February 5, 2013

    I hope all those singing in the finals are up to date with their finjancials in the association!!!!!!!!!

  66. Sweet Dominica
    February 5, 2013

    But Pembo was a judge at the semi finals and Delrose made it to the finals.I’m sure Pembo had the same view on the calypso at the time. Delrose you made it to the finals, the furthest you can reach. Crown? No way.

    • Not a herd follower
      February 5, 2013

      Put your brain on. Pembo was not the only judge

    • February 5, 2013

      Why is it that Dominicans just refuse to see the facts with this case as a judge he had no right to air his opinions regarding any of it while still on the pannel he was wrong therefore he should step down he had all the time to give his opinions after the final show is over why did he say those things And what about this Calypso that is touching so many nerves it’s a good one regardless if goes thru or not.

  67. Tri-State Beauty
    February 5, 2013

    Sometimes when we love to whisper loud, it comes out as an echo!

    • Admirer
      February 5, 2013

      Tri-State hmmmmmm. There’s an unrivalved finesse about you! What more can a man want? Real talk everytime you post something I imagine you in my arms!

      • Tut-Tut
        February 5, 2013

        but wait, why all you giving ADMIRER thumbs down? Let the man express his love for the woman, enough fighting going on already, let love reign. He’s not insulting or disrespecting her.y. Or is somebody else who admires her that jealous? OUCH see what TRIEE causing! ADMIRER you maybe well have her smiling. It’s truly nice to see a Dominican man always saying flattering things about a Dominican woman. Go on with your bad self ADMIRER

        Derose do right. He is entitled to an opionon, but people must remember what cap they’re wearing. Kaiso is controversy, let the games go on.

      • D A
        February 5, 2013

        You not sure if it’s a man but you would like to hold anyway.

      • Bettermann
        February 5, 2013

        Tri- State Beauty my name show that I am far better than Admirer. I therefore would like to express my interest.admirer does eat soap and he paroing too. Tri State Beauty only you cold make e jump from a mountain. Admirer would run from the mountain.
        Admirer you are done my unworthy opponent

      • To Be or Not To Be
        February 5, 2013

        But who said Tri-state Beauty is man or woman? Boy boy boy!

      • Tut-Tut
        February 6, 2013

        @ DA Tri-State Beauty 100% a woman. Men go to CHS? Go back and read postings of that person.

  68. mimi
    February 5, 2013

    But calypso this year have to much roro

  69. Jay
    February 5, 2013

    He maybe prejudge the show already. I honestly think he should not be allowed judge again. He has brought down the level of trust the calypso lovers had in him.

  70. Da
    February 5, 2013

    Pembo should give up his position in the same way that Hunter was presured into giving his up.
    Fair is Fair.

  71. Anonymous
    February 5, 2013

    so DNO,,, what did Pemberton day?

  72. positive mind
    February 5, 2013

    Very good. I wish Dice would have done the same cause there are certain people who stated clearly that they doh like Dice and they put this same person on the judges panel. I know of a certain person who does not leave in Dominica, but comes home for carnival and he judges sometimes. The way that person talks as long as he is a judge, Dice could never win a crown. That is so wrong.

  73. hmmm
    February 5, 2013

    DNO, I am sure your readers would be interested in exactly what Pemberton said on the radio talk show.

  74. Viewpoint
    February 5, 2013

    Stupes!!! But why is the Q95 Crew chookaiying so much kaka nuh??!! Derose get to the finals by a floops for his first and his last time, so why all this drama??!! Just sing your 2 mediocre songs and go at your home…

    • ?????????????
      February 5, 2013

      Q95 must make you burst a blood vessel…
      I LIKE THE STATION. It enlightens everyone,who likes what is right for Dominica and Dominicans.
      It has earned the reputation as the most listened to station in Dominica,because it is fearless in bringing out the TRUTH.

      • My2Sense
        February 5, 2013

        That is indeed sad.

        “It enlightens everyone”…? How sure are you of the validity or truth behind what is said on that station or any other station?

        Let us be real – Q95 may be the most listened to station, but it got that way not for be the most truthful. It got that way because the radio personalities entertain and argue the most controversial topics or they.

        Truth is another matter entirely.

      • ....................
        February 5, 2013

        @My2 cents….The statement is clear “It enlightens everyone who likes what is right for Dominica and Dominicans” Read properly.
        This statement is 100 000 000 000 000 000 000 000- 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 -000 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 000%% % % % % % % % % %% TRUTHFUL.

    • As if....
      February 6, 2013

      If I could have clicked the thumbs up 20 times I would have done it. Totally agree with you; especially for your last sentence.

    • kit
      February 6, 2013

      @viewpoint,he didn’t make it by a floops..he deserved to be in the finals..

  75. Jude Nicholas
    February 5, 2013

    What double standard is that. It is clear that Babs Dyer, Anthony Laronde and Gerard Smith should recluse themselves from sitting on the IPO.

    • *
      February 5, 2013

      @ Jude Nicholas It is also clear that Jude the moron/idiot Nicholas should recuse himself fron spewing filth and garbage, that should be buried at the landfil on this medium.

  76. wow
    February 5, 2013

    Pembo, as chief judge should have never gone on the show and said what he did. He messed up.

    The calypsonian is within his right.

    • Anonymous
      February 5, 2013

      very good derose stand for your right

    • Joe
      February 5, 2013

      What exactly did he say? I didn’t hear it so can you reproduce his exact statement??

      Thank you

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

:) :-D :wink: :( 8-O :lol: :-| :cry: 8) :-? :-P :-x :?: :oops: :twisted: :mrgreen: more »

 characters available